Forum Shopping in Patent Cases

Because patents rights are based on Federal law, forum shopping has always been a part of patent litigation.  Some plaintiffs choose the convenience or perceived security of a local courthouse while others go in search of districts with more favorable patent rules or juries.  In the years leading up to the formation of the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC), forum shopping was in full swing because of the varying treatment given to patent rights in the circuit courts of appeals. The Seventh Circuit, for instance, treated many issues differently than did the Second Circuit.  In the end, some circuits were entirely avoided by thoughtful patentees because of their track-record of invalidating or narrowing patent rights. More recently, the “rocket docket” of the Eastern District of Virginia was a great place to obtain a quick decision.  Today, however, the hot spot is the Eastern District of Texas (EDT) because of the impressive string of large jury verdicts.

TexasFlagEDT is so popular that it has its own specialized patent blog coverage — by attorney Michael Smith. (who I recently met at the AIPLA Chicago meeting). In a recent series of postings, Smith noted a milestone in the EDT history — the first defense verdict in years.  In Sensormatic v. WG Security Products, Inc., the jury came back with a verdict of non-infringement.  According to Smith:

The parties put on 14 live witnesses and 4 video-only witnesses in the space of four days plus one hour on Friday morning, which is about par for the length of a patent trial in Judge Ward’s court. This is the 21st patent verdict in the district in recent years that I am aware of, and the first defense verdict by a jury. 

For those of you interested in patent defense insurance — it appears that the defendant here was insured by Intellectual Property Insurance Services of Louisville, Kentucky.


  • Read Smith’s commentary here.


About Dennis Crouch

Law Professor at the University of Missouri School of Law. Co-director of the Center for Intellectual Property and Entrepreneurship.

10 thoughts on “Forum Shopping in Patent Cases

  1. Great XXX video collection sorted by genre. Regular update of porn-reels and movies, everything for free. Stop search for free porn-reels in the internet. Just login and download!

  2. Tramadol is a Pain killer abused by many, Huraaa for being a pharmacy effective pain reliever (analgesic). Its mode of action resembles that of narcotics, but it has significantly less potential for abuse and addiction than the narcotics.

    Tramadol is a Pain killer abused by many, Huraaa for being a pharmacy student.

  3. [url=]male submission female domination[/url]
    [url=]amp domination submission[/url]
    [url=]extreme foot fetish[/url]
    [url=]my friends hot mom mrs starr[/url]

  4. My new sites. Update bookmarks.

    [URL= link to ]nashville plastic surgeon[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]plastic surgery florida[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]costa rica plastic surgery[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]baxt[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]breast lift prices[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]boston reconstructive surgery[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]designer vagina[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]face lifts[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]face lift product[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]cosmetic surgery schools[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]plastic surgeon marin county[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]plastic surgery texas[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]gynecomastia surgery[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]plastic surgeon tunisian[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]abdominoplasty texas[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]abdominoplasty bakersfield[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]nj plastic surgeon[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]carpal tunnel surgery[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]addict high thigh[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]cosmetic surgery australia[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]breast surgery picture[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]hip plastic surgery[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]cost plastic surgery[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]plastic surgeon credentials[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]pasadena plastic surgeon[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]augmentaion breast surgery[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]endoscopic procedure[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]breast implant silicone[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]jowls plastic surgery[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]cosmetic surgery tunis[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]liposuction los angeles[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]plastic surgery des moines[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]face lift procedure[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]plastic surgeon canada[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]cosmetic surgery mexico[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]bakersfield tumescent liposuction[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]facial cosmetic surgery california[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]best plastic surgeon[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]breast implant picture[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]blepharoplasty cost[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]invasive non rhinoplasty[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]breast reconstruction new jersey[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]cosmetic surgeon white plains[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]cosmetic surgery tunisia[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]cosmetic surgery doctor[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]facial reconstructive surgery cleveland[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]cosmetic surgeon miami[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]tumescent technique[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]blepharoplasty post surgery[/URL]
    [URL= link to ]labiaplasty surgery[/URL]


  5. See Smith’s coverage of the latest defense verdict in the Eastern District of Texas which reports the first finding of patent invalidity by a jury in the district. link to

    Proud to say that I was part of the team representing the defendant, OutlookSoft Corporation.

  6. Just a clarification – Sensormatic is the first defense “jury” verdict I’m aware of. But there was a verdict for a defendant in a bench trial in 2002 (unfortunately I was representing the plaintiff!)

  7. Kimberly Moore was recently working on a paper about the need to revise the special patent venue statute to prevent forum shopping in patent cases to undue the effect of VE Holdings. I believe she made similar commetns in her Congressional testimony in the fall as well.

Comments are closed.