DC’s Prescription Drug Excessive Pricing Act of 2005, Down But Not Out

DCMAPBiotechnology Industry Organization v. District of Columbia (Fed. Cir.)

In October 2005, the District of Columbia (DC) enacted the “Prescription Drug Excessive Pricing Act of 2005.”  [Text]. As its name implies, the legislation prevents excessive pricing of patented drugs.

(a) A prima facie case of excessive pricing shall be established where the wholesale price of a patented prescription drug in the District is over 30 percent higher than the comparable price in any high income country in which the product is protected by patents or other exclusive marketing rights.

(b) [If a prima facie case is made, a defense is to show that the] given prescription drug is not excessively priced given demonstrated costs of invention, development and production of the prescription drug, global sales and profits to date, consideration of any government funded research that supported the development of the drug, and the impact of price on access to the prescription drug by residents and the government of the District of Columbia.

BIO and PhRMA immediately filed suit charging that the law was an unconstitutional violation of the Dormant Commerce Clause and the Foreign Commerce Clause, and asserted that the legislation was preempted under the Federal Patent Act. [Complaint].

The DC District Court quickly invalidated the legislation as both preempted and unconstitutional. [Opinion].

Now, the case is up on appeal at the Federal Circuit (05cv02015).

  • In a dramatic press release, WilmerHale calls the law “sweeping and draconian” …
  • STUDENT NOTE TOPIC: This case provides for an interesting note topic focusing on which appellate courts should have jurisdiction over constitutional and other challenges to the patent laws. (CAFC vs. Regional Circuits).

14 thoughts on “DC’s Prescription Drug Excessive Pricing Act of 2005, Down But Not Out

  1. 9

    well , i know you can lose weight by ding this kind of exercises and running stuff but for that u have work realy harder and it consumes alot of time . that’s why i suggest you better try Acomplia 20mg its safe and show fast results, its my personal expereince i have loss about 20 pounds with in juts 43 days without having any kind of side effect you can get it here with free worldwide shipping and yes for womens acomplia is the first choice
    link to ipetitions.com

  2. 6

    Acomplia (Rimonabant, Zimulti) is a non-controlled medication used in the treatment of obesity and management of body weight. The active ingredient of Acomplia is Rimonabant. It works by blocking specific receptors in the brain and fat tissues called CB1 receptors.


    Meridia/Reductil (SIBUTRAMINE HCI) is a prescription medication thats used to help people lose weight by acting on the appetite control centers in the brain. Studies have shown that using Meridia helps patients lose weight and maintain weight loss for up to 2 years.


  3. 4

    The most common combination used is in the form of the oral contraceptive pill (OCP). Treatment of endometriosis has involved the administration of drugs known as aromatase inhibitors (anastrozole [Arimidex] and letrozole [Femara] are examples). These drugs act by interrupting local estrogen formation within the endometriosis implants themselves. They also inhibit estrogen production in the ovary, brain, and other sources, such as adipose tissue
    link to drugs-prescription.org – Buy femara letrozole without prescription

    How can you determine if you are experiencing early menopause? If you are experiencing any of these symptoms, or others that are not listed and you suspect you may be experiencing pre-menopausal symptoms, it’s time to bring your speculations to your doctor.
    There are three main tests you can take to determine a menopause diagnosis –
    1.FSH test – A follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) test is used to test a woman’s FSH levels. If levels are high it’s a sign that the ovaries have stopped producing sufficient estrogen and could mean that the body has begun menopause.
    2.Blood test – You can ask your doctor for a blood test to determine estradiol levels. Estradiol is a form of estrogen and the levels decrease when the ovaries begin to fail. Therefore, low estradiol levels may be a sign of early menopause.
    3.Thyroid test – A thyroid test is a good idea because many perimenopause symptoms mirror thyroid problems. Therefore, this test will help you determine if what you are experiencing is indeed early menopause.
    If you are diagnosed with early menopause, you will find that there are different treatment options to help you cope with symptoms. Be sure to talk to you doctor about all possible treatments.
    link to drugs-prescription.org – Estradiol Climara PRO without prescription

    Your doctor may prescribe an oral antifungal agent to cure your yeast infection. The two main oral antifungals are Diflucan and Nizoral. The oral yeast infection medications have the advantage of being able to cure a yeast infection in one or two doses and you don’t have to deal with messy creams. The disadvantage to oral yeast infection medications is they may have side effects or interact with other medication you may be taking. Diflucan has a higher incidence of side effects such as, headaches, nausea, abdominal pain and dizziness. Nizoral has a lower incidence of side effects, but you cannot take it with many other medicines. Always tell you doctor or gynecologist what medicines you are taking. You should not take either of these oral antifungals while pregnant or breast-feeding.
    link to drugs-prescription.org – Parlodel Bromocriptine without prescription

    link to drugs-prescription.org – Buy diflucan fluconazole online

    The last commonly-prescribed medication for infertility is bromocriptine, which is sold as Parlodel. Women who have problems with ovulation that is related to high levels of prolactin can be helped by way of this kind of medicine. Prolactin is a hormone in the body that stimulates the production of milk.
    link to drugs-prescription.org – Duphaston Dydrogesterone without prescription

    Discount pharmacy http://www.pharmacywanted.com
    http://www.onlinepharmacy.ws – online pharmacy
    http://www.pharmacyonline.cc – pharmacy online
    http://www.rxwanted.net – discount pharmacy
    http://www.drugs-prescription.org – prescription drugs
    http://www.drugs-generic.info – generic drugs
    http://www.weightloss.lt – weight loss pills
    http://www.hairloss.lt – hair loss remedy, hair loss treatment, hair loss solution
    http://www.antibiotics.lt – antibiotics without prescription online
    http://www.diabetes.lt – diabetes disease treatment medication, herbs for diabetes
    http://www.herbal.lt – herbal remedy
    http://www.remediesherbal.org – herbal remedies
    http://www.trustedherbals.com – best herbal store
    http://www.trustedmeds.org – best medicines
    http://www.prescription-drugs-online.net – online prescription drugs
    http://www.discount-prescription-drugs.info – discount prescription drugs

  4. 3

    How do I keep up with the disposition of the case (i.e., whether the Federal Circuit will grant review)?

  5. 2

    How do I keep up with the disposition of the case (i.e., whether the Federal Circuit will grant review)?

  6. 1

    DoC should get a taste of their own medicine by enacting a law that states:

    (a) A prima facie case of government waste by the District of Columbia shall be established where the wholesale cost of an item or service acquired or offered by the District is over 30 percent higher than the comparable cost in any equal or higher income county in which a comparable item or service is acquired or offered.

Comments are closed.